Before start of show, Casey and you will Rusty was never ever most close as they stayed in several various other globes. Casey appeared to be extremely ashamed by the her cousin. When Casey came to CRU, she never ever stated the girl cousin, Rusty. She indeed wasn’t excited when he made a decision to arrive at CRU, however, is actually prepared to tolerate him and sometimes fulfill having a month-to-month brunch to capture upwards. Shortly after Rusty found to this lady one to Evan cheated for her and you may “defended the lady honor” of the hitting your regarding the face with a pledge paddle, the two of them provided to better its matchmaking and stay part of for each others’ lifetime. It been going to one another getting advice and you will consoled that various other whenever horrible anything taken place to every of them. Casey is actually prepared to assist Rusty which have relationship and you will matchmaking suggestions, but she would not assist him with one thing connected with his sex lifestyle. And when the guy did started to their to have suggestions about things intimate, Casey carry out get Ashleigh to aid him since the she is actually too shameful on the topic. The actual only real big date Casey got herself involved in Rusty’s sex life occurs when she attempted to prevent your of shedding his virginity to Lisa Lawson. She as well as attempts to protect Rusty from delivering damage psychologically as viewed whenever she told Ashleigh to not ever get involved in him, unless of course she is certain of this lady personal feelings for the your. Casey occasionally phone calls Rusty, “Russ” or “Jiminy Cricket”. Assuming Casey try enraged on him or attempts to score him to say any sort of they are covering up from the lady, she’s going to address Rusty since “Russell Allen”.
Cappie is actually Casey’s basic like. It dated to have 6 months beginning in the freshman 12 months and you will its lingering ideas per almost every other was a major plot range from the series. They earliest separated while the Cappie forgot when planning on taking Casey so you can new The Greek Golf ball. Regarding the Airplane pilot, it installed immediately following Evan duped into Casey, that have Evan afterwards accusing Casey out of nevertheless in love having Cappie. After Rusty advised Cappie you to Casey was being loused by the Evan he thought he need and you can victory the girl straight back, or discourage the woman off stating yes. Which looks like together creating a magazine together and you can kissing. Casey shuts it down and you will makes. In the last half of first 12 months no matter if Cappie are matchmaking Rebecca the guy however quite definitely has ideas to possess Casey. It afterwards reunite and you can go on to Arizona with her.
Casey and Evan was indeed the benefit few Greek Row however, infidelity and you can mistrust resulted in problem of their dating. Casey together with hates Rebecca Logan during much of season one because she slept that have Evan the initial nights rush. Through out the entire year, Casey manage label Rebecca horny otherwise create responses like “This is certainly throughout the trusting that the sisters are nevertheless here to you personally. That they can catch you after you slide, and you will trusting which they may not be skanky sluts which sleep having the man you’re dating.” Evan and you will Casey separated because the Frannie told Evan you to she persuaded Casey to remain that have your immediately following he cheated. She plus informed him one she cannot believe that Casey is actually more than Cappie. This leads to a large endeavor in which Evan holidays up with Casey, as he does not believe that Casey cares for your and therefore she didn’t simply tell him towards kiss having Cappie. Just after its breakup Evan de-loused Casey, and you will de-crowned the lady regarding Omega Chi sweetheart. Just after Casey says to Evan at the a party she continues to have ideas to have him he understands the guy also offers feelings on her behalf. But really he had been too late and you may Casey another early morning exhibited up from the their door advising Evan you to she simply wished to feel family members. Evan upcoming spends all of those other very first 12 months doing something which he believes tend to winnings her right back. Particularly getting household members together with her, providing Zeta Beta’s Mr. Purrfect champ Shane an one thousand dollar pay-off to not go out with Casey. And inside occurrence “A tale out-of One or free Dating In Your 40s two Events” Evan produces his nothing sibling stick to “Casey Obligations” that has been focus on disturbance ranging from Casey and you can people son you to she is actually speaking as well. He later on assists Casey analysis toward LSats. Frannie next manipulates Ashleigh into the telling Shane away from,once the she already understands the trick. Which after that provokes Shane so you’re able to informing Ashleigh just what most occurred. She basically says to Evan which he has to move on.